OTTY
OTTY vs Silentnight
OTTY vs Silentnight UK 2026
OTTY Original — from our UK review
4.4/5 — the one we slept on
- Default mattress
- OTTY Original · 25cm · 7/10
- From-price
- £499.99 vs £569
- Trial (direct)
- 100 nights vs 60
- Warranty
- 10 years vs 5
Affiliate links to the live UK shops. No extra cost to you.
Reviewed by
James Wright
Lead Product Tester
Tested by
Sarah, Emma, David, Rachel
Updated · Published · 12 min read · Contains affiliate links. Affiliate disclosure.
Live UK prices · OTTY checked · Silentnight checked .
Default pick
OTTY Original Hybrid
The only mattress here we have slept on, from £499.99 with 100 nights and ten years against Silentnight’s 60 nights and five. Buy Silentnight instead if you want a shop-floor lie-down first or you already want the hotel bed.
- 4.4/5 in our review
- From £499.99
- 100-night trial
- 25cm · 7/10
OTTY from-prices checked 5 September 2026. OTTY discounts hard — open the live size picker before you pay.
OTTY Original Hybrid. Order it.
4.4/5. From £499.99. 25cm. Medium-firm 7/10. Up to 2,000 × 16cm pocket springs. 100-night collection trial. 10-year warranty. Free 2-man UK mainland drop. James at 86kg / 13st 8lb would buy it on a sale. Sarah at 62kg / 9st 11lb found 7/10 plenty — a bit firm on her side. David at 104kg / 16st 5lbwanted Extra Firm. That is the product. Not a 4.9 sticker.
OTTY vs Silentnight scorecard
Brand against brand, using each one’s default mattress rather than a blended average.
| Fact | OTTY | Silentnight | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Default buy | Original Hybrid · 4.4/5 · slept on | No default we have slept on | OTTY |
| From-price | £499.99 Original · £325 Aura | £569 Lift Replenish · £649 hotel 2.0 | OTTY |
| Trial | 100 nights · collection · ~30 nights first | 60 nights · retailer · often exchange | OTTY |
| Warranty | 10 years boxed hybrids | 5 years most · 6 hotel · 10 Studio | OTTY |
| Lie-down first | No UK shop-floor network | Dreams, John Lewis, Bensons, 500+ stores | Silentnight |
| Delivery | Boxed 2-man · extras for removal | Retailer van or Silentnight.co.uk | Tie |
| Made-in story | UK company · Leeds 0113 · boxed origin: ask | Barnoldswick · Royal Warrant marketing | Silentnight |
| Heavier sleeper | Extra Firm 9/10–10/10 we slept on | Ortho / Mirapocket story — untested here | OTTY |
Who buys what
Find the line that describes you, then buy the mattress next to it.
| If you are… | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Typical UK sleeper, mixed positions, want a boxed hybrid tonight | Buy | OTTY Original. 4.4/5. From £499.99. 100-night collection trial. We slept on it. |
| Around 15st+, back/stomach, you actually want a hard bed | Buy | OTTY Extra Firm. Flip 9/10 or 10/10. David Patel at 104kg kept it. Not Original “plus a bit”. |
| Guest room or the cheapest current hybrid | Buy on sale | OTTY Aura from £325. 23cm. Do not spend Original money on weekend visitors. |
| You already liked a current Premier Inn bed and want that model | Trial first | Premier Inn Mattress 2.0 from £649. Hotel pillowtop. No advertised sleep trial. We have not slept on it. |
| You want to lie on it in Dreams / John Lewis / Bensons first | Trial first | Silentnight wins the shop-floor test. 60-night retailer trial after that. Still not a 100-night OTTY refund. |
| You need 200 nights to decide | Skip | Neither brand. OTTY is 100. Silentnight core range is 60, often exchange-only. Open Emma or Simba. |
Buy OTTY if
You will use a 100-night home trial
You want a named default: Original, 7/10, from £499.99
You might actually need Extra Firm — OTTY sells that as its own model
You want a Leeds phone number, not a shop-floor hop
Buy OTTY OriginalBuy Silentnight if
You refuse to buy a bed you have not sat on in store
You already liked Premier Inn and want the official 2.0
You want latex over 2000 Mirapocket (Lift Replenish) and accept 60 nights
You want the 37cm UltraGel pillowtop and will pick Soft or Firm
Open SilentnightWhich model — do not buy the logo
You are buying one mattress, not a brand. These are the six worth considering between the two ranges.
OTTY
Original Hybrid
OTTY
Extra Firm Hybrid
15st+ · back/stomach · you asked for hard
4.0/5 · 25cm · 9/10 or 10/10 flip · from £500 · slept on
OTTY
Aura Hybrid
Guest room. Not a nightly side-sleeper main bed.
4.1/5 · 23cm · from £325 · no UK small double
Silentnight
Lift Replenish Hybrid 2000
Latex over 2000 Mirapocket — not slept on yet
From £569 · 60 nights · 5 years · height not printed
Silentnight
UltraGel Cool-to-touch 3000
37cm cooling pillowtop · Soft or Firm
From £789 · 60 nights · we have not slept on it
Silentnight
Premier Inn Mattress 2.0
Only if you already liked that hotel bed
From £649 · 28.5cm · no advertised trial · 6-year guarantee
Full ranges: which OTTY to buy · Silentnight brand page.
Price, trial, warranty — the buy maths
Price
OTTY Original from £499.99 including VAT (single, ).
SLEEPWELL26 was 8% off over £400 that day. Codes die. Check live.
Silentnight Lift Replenish from £569 (). Hotel 2.0 from £649. UltraGel from £789.
Do not pay a quiet RRP on either brand.
Trial
Warranty + van
OTTY boxed hybrids: 10 years, defects not “it hugged more in month one”. Free 2-man drop. Room-of-choice and old-mattress removal are extras.
Silentnight: 5 years on most, 6 on hotel 2.0, 10 on Studio. Retailer delivery rules win if you bought in-store.
OTTY phone 01133 202 490. Silentnight 0333 123 0892.
Stop reading. Check the live ticket.
Sale codes die. Size pickers move. The 100-night trial is the product on OTTY.
Named testers — not a panel average
James Wright
86kg / 13st 8lb · Back/side combination
“Original is the OTTY I would order. I used to sign off Silentnight beds. That does not make Lift Replenish the buy when I have not slept on it. 100 nights beats 60.”
Sarah Mitchell
62kg / 9st 11lb · Side sleeper
“Original’s 7/10 was plenty — a bit firm on my side at 62kg. I would not spend Silentnight pillowtop money on a mattress nobody here has slept on. Use the OTTY trial.”
Emma Thompson
71kg / 11st 2lb · Side-dominant combination
“Do not put a side sleeper on Extra Firm. That is a bruise. Pure+ is the OTTY with somewhere for a shoulder. Silentnight UltraGel is a 37cm story until we sleep on it.”
David Patel
104kg / 16st 5lb · Back sleeper; sits on the edge
“Aura bottomed out under 104kg. Original was usable. Extra Firm is the one I kept. A Silentnight “ortho” badge is not a night I have had.”
When Silentnight still wins
I am not going to pretend Barnoldswick does not exist. Silentnight is the UK shop-floor brand. That is a real reason to buy — if it is your reason.
Buy Silentnight
You will lie on it in Dreams / John Lewis / Bensons today
You already slept well in that hotel and want the official Premier Inn 2.0
You want latex + 2000 Mirapocket and accept a 60-night retailer trial
You want the current UltraGel 37cm cool-to-touch pillowtop
Do not buy Silentnight
You wanted a 100-night cash-style collection trial — that is OTTY
You wanted a default we have actually slept on
You thought “NHS / Royal Warrant” was a feel rating
You need 200 nights — walk to Emma or Simba
The case against OTTY
Nothing here earns a perfect five. If any of these are deal-breakers for you, walk.
- 100 nights is half Emma / Eve / Simba. If the paperwork is the product, skip both brands here.
- Aura and Extra Firm do not list a UK small double. Pure+ does not either.
- Extra Firm will punish a side sleeper. Emma Thompson lasted one bad night.
- Old-mattress removal is an extra on OTTY, not part of the free 2-man van.
- Summer codes die. SLEEPWELL26 was live 20 August 2026. It may not be tomorrow.
OTTY vs Silentnight FAQ
Final call
Buy OTTY Original. Use the 100 nights.
James Wright, 86kg / 13st 8lb, former Silentnight QC: I would not spend Silentnight money on a mattress we have not slept on when Original is from £499.99 and we have. Silentnight if you need a shop-floor sit. Everyone else: order the OTTY.
Contains affiliate links. How we make money.
Winner
OTTY Original